Daisy Morgan, a recent Part II graduate from the Department of Plant Sciences, is this year’s winner of the Sir Albert Howard Travel Exhibition. She used the award to fund a two-month research trip to Java, Indonesia, exploring ecosystems and plant diversity within local coffee agroforestry plantations.
**
Thanks to generous funding and support from the Sir Albert Howard Travel Exhibition and the Department of Plant Sciences, I spent two months in Java this summer working on my project ‘Ecosystem service provision and plant diversity in coffee agroforestry plantations’.
Southeast Asia produces over a quarter of the world’s coffee, with Indonesia producing around 7% of the global output – 96% of which is cultivated on smallholder farms. Agroforestry – combining agricultural crops or livestock with trees and shrubs – has many benefits, including improving soil health, mitigating climate change effects and providing wildlife habitat.
This means that using agroforestry systems for coffee in Indonesia has significant potential to contribute to the sustainability of agriculture and biodiversity conservation.
However, coffee agroforestry remains understudied in Southeast Asia and globally there has been limited assessment of agroforestry’s impact on non-crop plant biodiversity and the role of understorey vegetation – despite Java representing a key region of geographical interest as the world's most populous island.
My project aimed to address some of these knowledge gaps by assessing different vegetation structures within the agroforestry systems in Java and exploring their impact on ecosystem service provision and yields.
Fieldwork in bird-friendly Jatimulyo
During my trip, I collaborated with Mukhlish Jamal Musa Holle from the Faculty of Biology at Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM) in Yogyakarta, undertaking fieldwork with two of his students: Wafa and Alifa. Our study sites were coffee plantations around Kopi Sulingan in the village of Jatimulyo, Kulon Progo Regency, in the Special Region of Yogyakarta. Each coffee site was owned and farmed by a different person, with different management techniques resulting in agroforestry systems with a range of vegetation characteristics.
Jatimulyo is a ‘bird-friendly’ village, where local people transitioned from hunting birds to conservation and eco-tourism 10 years ago over fears of driving local species to extinction. ‘Sulingan’ is the local name for Cyornis banyumas – an endemic bird, critically endangered through habitat loss and the caged bird trade. Our guide, Mas Pangat – who also represents the Wanapaksi Forest Farmers Group – led us around the sites, explaining the history of the area and teaching us about the local bird and plant species.
A key part of my research focused on variations in canopy closure, tree density and understorey complexity across the sites. I investigated microclimate regulation and pest predation, although insufficient coffee flowering prevented the assessment of insect pollination. I also collected non-destructive proxies for yield.
Alongside this field data, we spoke to each landowner to understand the history and management of the sites, recent yields, and their primary concerns regarding coffee production.
Evaluating ecosystem services and presenting at UGM
Following the fieldwork, I returned to Yogyakarta to analyse leaf photographs for disease, pest and herbivore damage and also assessed plasticine caterpillars we’d left out in the field for attack rates from arthropods, birds and mammals. I then integrated the data with interview findings to submit a report to the agency that issued my research permit.
For microclimate, I found that canopy closure buffered temperatures and there were clear links with both temperature and humidity for understorey biodiversity. Some of the farmers we spoke to, whose sites had lower canopy closure, were concerned about increasingly high temperatures leading to coffee plants dying and failing to flower. Optimising agroforestry practices may be a good way to combat such pressures from climate change.
Speaking to farmers also highlighted other critical context-dependent dynamics; for instance, while vegetation provides habitat for beneficial pest predators, it may also support coffee berry-eating animals such as civets and fruit bats. Although the yield data collected was limited, it was inversely correlated with leaf damage, suggesting that managing for higher canopy cover and understorey vegetation complexity can benefit coffee yields through ecosystem service provision.
At the end of the trip, I presented my project and future research ideas at the Faculty of Biology UGM to Jamal’s students, several of whom were interested in continuing the research for their thesis projects. It was exciting to discuss with them and makes me happy at the prospect of the work being continued!
Exploring tropical landscapes and bringing lectures to life
Beyond the main project, being in Java provided a wonderful opportunity to explore tropical landscapes connected to my degree.
Having conducted a Part II project on sustainable rice agronomy, I found visiting local rice paddies and observing system-level strategies – such as barn owl boxes for natural pest management – was particularly engaging. My field assistants, Alifa and Wafa, are undertaking thesis projects in paddies utilising polyculture and barn owl conservation, researching how embankment plantings of taro, banana, and alpine grass affect soil erosion and insect populations.
I also wrote my critical review essay in Part II on carbon credits in Blue Carbon Ecosystems, an example of which is mangroves. In Jakarta, I met up with a fellow Part II Plant Sciences student and was excited to visit a large mangrove restoration and eco-tourism project on the city’s northern coast: Taman Wisata Alam Angke Kapuk.
With the restoration activities, vegetation cover here has increased by 477% between 1999 and 2021, bringing a wide range of benefits. As well as sequestering (blue) carbon and leading to the recovery of biodiversity, the proximity of the park to the city means the impact on air quality and coastal protection and its cultural services are particularly realised.
The coastal protection it provides is especially beneficial as Jakarta is the world’s fastest-sinking city. It was fascinating to learn more about the restoration activities and plant species there, as well as enjoying general wildlife spotting.
Developing skills for a future career
This trip has been immensely valuable for my development as a scientist. Planning an independent project, securing research permits, managing fieldwork logistics, and engaging with local stakeholders provided crucial experience.
These skills have directly helped me secure my next role on an agroforestry project with Forest Research. Furthermore, this project has inspired and benefitted my current applications for PhDs in sustainable agricultural systems, focusing on the impacts of climate change and strategies for mitigating them.
**
About the Sir Albert Howard Travel Exhibition
The Sir Albert Howard Travel Exhibition was set up in 1947 to support students to travel abroad for botanical research. The award is open to students offering Plant Sciences in Part II of the Natural Sciences Tripos each year. An alumnus of St John’s College, Cambridge, Sir Albert Howard completed both his undergraduate and master’s degrees there, graduating in 1903.
If you would like to support for the department’s activities, by making a gift, you will be supporting fundamental scientific research of the highest quality and an innovative programme of world-class teaching. No matter what the size of the gift, it will be greatly appreciated.
Find out more: Support Plant Sciences
Images: Top of page – the project team (left to right) Jamal, Wafa, Mas Pangat, Daisy, Ibu Sri (accommodation host) and Alifa. Credit: Mukhlish Jamal Musa Holle. Bottom of page – (left to right) measuring canopy closure in the agroforestry; the mangroves; the rice paddy with polyculture embankment planting / owl boxes. Credits: Daisy Morgan.